| Children |
| | 1. Lucy Shurtleff, b. 9 Oct 1751, Middleborough, Plymouth, Massachusetts d. Yes, date unknown |
| | 2. Mary Shurtleff, b. 7 Jun 1753, Middleborough, Plymouth, Massachusetts d. Yes, date unknown |
| | 3. Thomas Shurtleff, b. 3 Apr 1756, Middleborough, Plymouth, Massachusetts d. Yes, date unknown |
 | 4. Simeon Shurtleff, b. 23 Jun 1758, Middleborough, Plymouth, Massachusetts d. Yes, date unknown |
 | 5. Elizabeth Shurtleff, b. 8 Feb 1761, Middleborough, Plymouth, Massachusetts d. Yes, date unknown |
| | 6. Jonathan Shurtleff, b. 25 Jan 1764, Middleborough, Plymouth, Massachusetts d. Yes, date unknown |
| | 7. Anna Shurtleff, b. 10 Jan 1766, Middleborough, Plymouth, Massachusetts d. Yes, date unknown |
| | 8. Giles Shurtleff, b. 19 Jan 1768, Middleborough, Plymouth, Massachusetts d. Yes, date unknown |
| | 9. Mehitable Shurtleff, b. 23 Feb 1770 d. Yes, date unknown |
| | 10. Phoebe Shurtleff, b. 22 May 1774, Middleborough, Plymouth, Massachusetts d. Yes, date unknown |
|