| Children |
| | 1. Mercy Atwater, b. Feb 1646/47, New Haven, New Haven, Connecticut |
| | 2. Damaris Atwater, b. 12 Nov 1648, Old Lyme, New London, Connecticut |
| | 3. David Atwater, b. 13 Jul 1650, New Haven, New Haven, Connecticut |
| | 4. Joshua Atwater, b. 11 Jan 1651/52, Old Lyme, New London, Connecticut |
| | 5. John Atwater, b. 1 Nov 1654, Old Lyme, New London, Connecticut |
| | 6. Jonathan Atwater, b. 12 Jul 1656, Old Lyme, New London, Connecticut |
| | 7. Abigail Atwater, b. 3 Mar 1659/60, Old Lyme, New London, Connecticut |
| | 8. Mary Atwater, b. 31 Mar 1662, New Haven, New Haven, Connecticut |
| | 9. Samuel Atwater, b. 17 Sep 1664, New Haven, New Haven, Connecticut |
| | 10. Ebenezer Atwater, b. 13 Jan 1666/67, New Haven, New Haven, Connecticut |
|